Saturday, February 28, 2015

Posted On 2/28/2015 by Team iCynosure.

No two moments in life are the same; change is the only constant in life. And that change is the inspiration behind every innovation and invention that finds its way from the inventor’s lab to the common man’s house. 

Fueled by technology the goal of every invention is to make lives easier and convenient; however it is not the case always. Sometimes the invention in itself defeats the purpose for which it was made. 

As any Indian the two things that drove me crazy were Cinema and Cricket and not necessarily in that order. Though Cricket is not our national game, it is by far the most loved and followed sport in India. There will hardly be any household in the country that doesn't keep abreast with the ongoing games. It is the game that unites people of India wherever they are, whenever it is played and whatever the situation.

However over the last few years, there is a battle drawn between the game and the management / players; especially Indian. The growing unrest born of the controversial DRS system that Indian authorities refuse to acknowledge as part of the game has left the viewer astonished. The flak and embarrassment that this has caused the Indian cricket fan is unmentionable. 

This has had me thinking a game that is more traditionally chivalrous today become more impolite and rude. And whether relying on technology will be more of a Boon or a Bane that will take it to it's former glory is yet to be seen,  

Though there are innumerable technological interference in cricket, some of the most prominent ones can be seen in the form of the following…. 

Hot Spot 
True to the name, the Hot-Spot technology uses the Heat of Ball Impact via infrared cameras to judge crucial decision of nicks and lbws. Unfortunately the huge cost of equipment doesn’t allow its use as much as it would benefit the game. 

Stump Camera 
I guess it is the longest used technology in the cricketing arena. It’s more applicable for giving a closer view to the viewers than to benefit the game. However since the last few games, I’ve seen a LED stump used that lightens when the stumps are hit by the ball or the bails are dislodged during stumping or a run-out. 

TV Repeat Technology
Technology used to updates umpires and players about various glitches in the game. From whether the hit is a four or a six to whether the catch was cleanly taken or not to whether the ball was a no-ball or not and many such instances. 

Decision Review System
Just like in various other sports, a player can refer a decision made by an on-field umpire for review. The third empire than uses various technological avenues at his disposal to arrive at a decision to either go with the on-field decision or reverse it. It helps minimise decision errors that could actually change the outcome of the game. 

Have you ever thought about the match outcomes if there was a chance to review these horrendous umpiring decision?

Sachin Tendulkar given LBW against Australia by Steve Bucknor 
AB de Villiers given not out to Zaheer Khan by Aleem Dhar 

And that's just warming up to the ugliest on-flied decision, there are loads more. 

So if you read through, you may feel that there are only pros to using technology and no cons. But like every coin has two sides, technology too does. Technology is great, up until it is used wisely and unanimously. Some people argue that technological interference also takes away from the human element of the game. Monetary repercussions too weigh heavily on the participating nations and the flight of fancy that some nations are able to pull their weight on using the systems.  

Additional options for better and accurate decision making
Eliminates doubt, reduces friction among players
Gives the game a chance of the best possible fair result 
Not 100% full proof
Unnecessary waste of time, in case of multiple reviews
Huge investments needed to have a universally solid system

For me, I’m a big fan of technology, especially when it helps to eliminate doubt and draw a consensus and so for me it definitely has a place in the game. 

Many may not agree with me, but that’s the beauty of the human mind. No two minds think alike, and each mind is open for change.
- Heena

The views and the descriptions here within stems from my limited knowledge of the game and the technology used, however they are expressed in immense desire to be part of Harsha Bhogle’s #BloggerDreamTeam.   


Post a Comment